One of the greatest challenges we’ve faced with Leah (aside from breastfeeding) is sleep training. Sleep is one of the most talked about issues among parents, and now I know why. Sleep and good sleep habits one of those things that is always changing, hard to master, but highly desired.
There is so much to say about sleep training, but since this the first post on the topic (and I can’t write it all in one post) I’ll just start off by giving you a list of the most valuable lessons I learned:
1) Read Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child
- This book is the “Bible” of sleep training and practically every mom I’ve talked to has recommended it. Though it is sometimes hard to understand (maybe I was too sleep deprived), it takes a balanced approach to sleep training and doesn’t force one method over another. Instead it gives you several options at each stage and so you can pick which method suits your parenting style best. Which leads me to:
2) Pick an approach and method that you are comfortable with - There are a lot of different approaches out there for sleep training, but like a lot of parenting topics, I believe that there isn’t one right or wrong way to do things. Each child is unique and requires an approach that works best for that child, and for the parents. That’s why I found the Healthy Sleep Habits book is so helpful. I also read The Baby Whisperer and The No-Cry Sleep Solution but they are very specific in telling you what you should and should not do. Methods like soothing the baby to sleep through patting or nursing, or allowing the baby to cry-it-out (CIO) was frowned upon. The Healthy Sleep Habits book gives you the option of soothing your baby to sleep (through nursing or patting) or allowing the baby to CIO and explains how to adapt the methods accordingly. Even with the CIO method, he explains how to do so gradually (going back in to soothe the baby at increasing time increments) if this suits you better.
3) Be consistent and be strong- It will be much easier to follow this tip if you follow tip #2 and pick a method that you are comfortable with. If you pick a method that you’re not comfortable with, or try something before you’re ready, you’re more like to revert back to what you were doing before. This inconsistency will make it harder for your child and for you. Also keep in mind that it will take some time for your child to learn how to develop good sleep habits and it will usually get hard before it gets better. In the process of following these sleep training methods (especially if you choose to let your child CIO) its important to be strong! Remember that there must be so short term pain for long term gain. If you give in too early and revert back to what you were doing before, the inconsistency will make the process longer and harder in the long run.
4) Have a support system – Find a fellow parent who can support you in the process who has the foresight of having gone through the sleep training process with their child. Preferably find someone who knows you and your spouse, and your child’s temperament so that they can guard you against your weaknesses and help validate if you are using the right method for your child’s personality. You’ll want to find the person who can support without judging and give you the right push at the right time. It’s also great to have someone to update when things go well and to vent to when challenges arise.
Our experience with sleep training Leah:
To give you some history, here is a brief history of Leah’s sleeping habits up to now:
Months 0 to 2: DAY: in our arms; NIGHT: co-sleeper; METHOD: No-Cry Method
Month 2 to 3.5: DAY: in our arms; NIGHT: crib, in our room; METHOD: No-Cry Method
Month 3.5 to 5: DAY: crib; NIGHT: crib, in our room; METHOD: No-Cry Method
Month 5 to 7: DAY: crib; NIGHT: crib in our room; METHOD: Cry-It-Out Method
In the first 3.5 months, Leah would cry every time we tried to put her down to sleep so she ended up sleeping in our arms for all of her day time naps. For her night sleep (her bedtime was around 10pm), I would nurse her to sleep or Clayton would pat her to sleep before we put her down in her crib. If she woke up crying either when we put her down, or sometime during the night, we would start over again. I really enjoyed holding her while we slept, but the process of nursing, patting, slowly lowering her down into her crib for her night time sleep (and eventually for her day time naps), was a long and tedious process. It required a lot of patience and her nap times became the most stressful times of the day. At night it would sometimes take hours of patting and nursing until we could put her down in her crib without her waking up again. In some instances she would be crying while we were trying to her to sleep. We realized that she was becoming too aware of what she needed to do to be held and wasn’t getting enough deep sleep as a result.
We finally decided to try the CIO method (she was crying half the time in our arms anyway!). For us it was the right method at that time, and for Leah’s temperament it was necessary. We did the CIO Extinction method because we knew that going back in the room at intervals would only make things worse. The first day we did it, she fell asleep nursing during her daytime naps so there wasn’t any crying. The first time we let her CIO for the night time sleep she cried for 35 minutes. I was on the phone with my support system mom and while she was convincing me that it was going to be okay, Leah stopped crying and fell asleep! From that point onwards her sleeping improved dramatically! She woke up only 2 times a night (or less) for feeds, her bedtime moved from 10:30pm to 7pm and her naps stretched out from 3o minutes to an average of 1 hour with occasional 2 or 3 hour naps. Clayton and I were so relieved to see her sleeping so well and we had our evenings back! It was incredible.
These days she cries less than 5 minutes before falling asleep unless she falls asleep nursing. She generally wakes up once (or not at all) between 7pm and 7am. We’re so happy with her sleep habits (for now at least!) and would definitely attribute our success to following the tips I outlined above.